In today’s fast-paced business landscape, dependable networking is critical and switches are essential for creating a secure and efficient network. With so many switches on the market, knowing which one to choose can be tough. In this article, we’ll compare two outstanding switches-FS S3910-24TS and Cisco C9200L 24T 4G to help you decide which one is the best fit for your business.
Performance
The performance of a switch is a critical factor in ensuring that a network can meet the demands of modern applications and support the needs of a growing business. FS S3910-24TS is a gigabit Layer 2+ stackable managed switch that features 24x 10/100/1000BASE-T ports and 4x 10Gb SFP+ uplinks, with the Broadcom BCM56150 switch chip. Furthermore, FS S3910-24TS provides 128 Gbps switching capacity and 96 Mpps forwarding rate to deliver higher network performance. Cisco C9200L 24T 4G provides 24 ports data, 4x 1G fixed uplinks. It has a 56 Gbps switching capacity and a 41.66 Mpps forwarding rate. From this perspective, FS S3910-24TS offers higher performance with a larger switching capacity and forwarding rate compared to the Cisco C9200L 24T 4G, satisfying various customer business requirements to a greater extent.
Scalability
A switch with good scalability can support more devices and users, which is very important for applications, especially in large network environments such as enterprises and data centers. FS S3910-24TS supports 4 units of virtual stacking to deliver redundancy, simple management, and resilience of network capacity. It also supports IPv4/IPv6 and rich layer 3 routing features including static routing, Open Shortest Path First (OSPF), Routing Information Protocol (RIP), RIPng, etc. In addition, FS S3910-24TS’s 24 gigabit RJ45 ports allow connecting multiple devices according to different bandwidths, offering a more flexible network connection. Cisco C9200L 24T 4G supports stacking up to 8 members. It also has layer 3 capabilities, including Open Shortest Path First (OSPF), Enhanced Interior Gateway Routing Protocol (EIGRP), Routing Information Protocol (RIP), and routed access. Overall, the FS S3910-24TS gigabit switch can better support network expansion and upgrades, thereby better enabling flexible deployments for diverse networking demands.
Stability and Security
The stability and security of switches are key factors that ensure the normal operation of the entire computer network and need to be highly valued and strengthened. FS S3910-24TS is equipped with 2 (1+1 Redundancy) hot-swappable power supply as default, with input voltage 100-240VAC,50-60Hz. It has 1 built-in fan. Power Supply Units (PSUs) can be removed/replaced without shutting down the system, and the variable-speed fan with right-to-left airflow for superior cooling, noise, and power reduction. For security, FS S3910-24TS supports the secure shell protocol (SSH), Access Control List (ACL), AAA (IPv4/IPv6),802.1X, RADIUS, TACACS+, etc. Cisco C9200L 24T 4G is packed with field-replaceable unit (FRU) dual power supplies and dual fans. FRU can be quickly and easily removed/replaced by the user or by a technician without having to send the entire product or system to a repair facility. For security, Cisco C9200L 24T 4G offers AES-128 MACsec encryption for data safety. It also supports Quality of Service (QoS), including granular wireless bandwidth management and fair sharing,802.1p Class of Service (CoS) and Differentiated Services Code Point (DSCP) field classification, Shaped Round Robin (SRR) scheduling, and Committed Information Rate (CIR). Both switches can supply stable networks and effectively protect your data information.
Software
The software of a switch is the foundation for implementing its various functions and services. FS S3910-24TS is configured with Airware and Airbox networks. FS Airware is a cloud management service, which offers the full range of features from planning, deployment, and operation to optimization. It pacifically caters to small and medium-sized enterprises and multi-branch organizations and can aid in enhancing operational efficiency while minimizing IT manpower expenditure across various branch offices. Cisco C9200L 24T 4G applies Cisco IOS XE, opening a completely new paradigm in network configuration, operation, and monitoring through network automation. It owns SD-Access, an extensible software-driven architecture that accelerates and simplifies your enterprise network operations. Both switches have outstanding management systems for operation, but Cisco C9200L 24T 4G has more software features that bring great convenience and benefits to network administration.
Warranty&Support
Dependable warranty and technical support services can build consumers’ trust and loyalty in the corporate brand. FS S3910-24TS provides a 5-year limited warranty against defects in materials or workmanship. Furthermore, FS provides a personal account manager, free professional technical support, and 24/7 live customer service to each customer. Once you encounter problems during product installation and use, you can find direct and immediate assistance from an expert. Cisco C9200L 24T 4G comes with a Cisco Enhanced Limited Lifetime Warranty (E-LLW) that includes Next-Business-Day (NBD) delivery of replacement hardware where available and 90 days of 8×5 Cisco Technical Assistance Center (TAC) support. Compared to FS S3910-24TS, the warranty service of the Cisco C9200L 24T 4G is more limited.
Cost-effectiveness
According to the information on the official website, the price of the Cisco C9200L 24T 4G switch is much higher than the FS S3910-24TS switch under a similar number of ports and functions, making the FS S3910-24TS switch a more cost-effective choice. If you prefer to purchase products with high cost-effectiveness, then FS S3910-24TS is more suitable.Below is a table that briefly compares the specifications of FS S3910-24TS and Cisco C9200L 24T 4G.
| Specification | FS S3910-24TS | Cisco C9200L 24T 4G |
| Ports | 24x 10/100/1000BASE-T RJ45, 4x 1G/10G SFP+ | 24 Ports Data, 4x 1G Fixed Uplinks |
| Forwarding Rate | 96 Mpps | 41.66 Mpps |
| Switching Capacity | 128 Gbps | 56 Gbps |
| Stackability | 4 Members | 8 Members |
| Power Supply | 2 (1+1 Redundancy) Hot-swappable | Dual FRU Power Supply |
| Fan | 1 Built-in | Fixed Redundant |
| Input Voltage | 100-240VAC, 50-60Hz, 2A | 100 to 240 VAC,50 to 60 Hz (PWR-C5-125WAC) |
| Max. Power Consumption | 27W | 125W |
| Price | Varies ( around US$700) | Varies (＞US$ 1,000) |
Conclusion
To sum up, we can know that each of these two switches has its own advantages. If you need a network switch with high cost-effectiveness, excellent performance, more guaranteed warranty service, and superior scalability, FS S3910-24TS will be a good choice. These diverse features of FS S3910-24TS can help customers better meet their growing network requirements. If you need a more flexible network configuration and more comprehensive software services, then the Cisco C9200L 24T 4G switch is more suitable for your needs. When choosing a switch, you should consider it based on your actual demand and budget. No matter which one you purchase, we believe these switches can provide practical performance and reliable connectivity for your business.
